About Rental Guys Property Management
Rental Guys Property Management is a family-run Jacksonville company that has managed single-family and multi-family rentals since 2012, specializing in Nocatee and St. Johns County and serving Ponte Vedra and the Jacksonville Beaches.
Review summary: Most reviewers mention dependable tenant placement, fair terms, fast responses and caring staff.
Years in business from the company's website: “Rental Guys Property Management has been helping property owners successfully manage rental homes in Jacksonville and St. Johns County since 2012.”
Written by our team from the company's Google listing and website.
What we checked
- Google listing open, checked October 2026
- Manages rentals for other owners (our property-manager check)
- Website read on November 4, 2026
- Newest Google review: October 26, 2026
Not checked by us
- Florida license records (coming soon)
- Fees and contract terms: ask for a written quote
- Insurance
- Service quality beyond Google reviews
No company pays to be listed or ranked. How we choose companies
At a glance
Property types
- Single-family homes
- Multi-family
Services
- Leasing
- Marketing
- Maintenance
- Multi-family management
Areas served
- Jacksonville
- St. Johns
- St. Augustine
- Nocatee
- Ponte Vedra
- Jacksonville Beaches
- Mandarin
- Southside
- Julington Creek
- Atlantic Beach
- World Golf Village
From the company's website, checked November 4, 2026.
How they work with owners
- Owner statements
- “Access detailed income and expense reports, statements, and important documents anytime through your secure owner portal — giving you full visibility into your property’s performance.” Source
- Inspections
- “We perform detailed property inspections throughout the lease term, including renewal inspections, to document the condition of your property and identify any maintenance concerns.” Source
Copied word for word from the company's website, read November 4, 2026.
Office and hours
11250 Old St Augustine Rd #15, Jacksonville, FL 32257
| Monday | 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM |
| Tuesday | 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM |
| Wednesday | 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM |
| Thursday | 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM |
| Friday | 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM |
| Saturday | Closed |
| Sunday | Closed |
Hours from Google. Call ahead to confirm.
Google rating
Topics reviewers mention
- Tenant placement 15
- Fair terms 3
- Tenant experience 3
- Fast response time 3
- Caring staff 2
- Rent payment 2
- Property care 2
- Tenant screening 2
- Maintenance issues 2
- Family run business 2
Source: Google. Newest review October 26, 2026. We show counts only, never review text. Read the reviews on Google
Questions about Rental Guys Property Management
Where is Rental Guys Property Management located?
Rental Guys Property Management's office is at 11250 Old St Augustine Rd #15, Jacksonville, FL 32257.
How long has Rental Guys Property Management been in business?
Since 2012, about 14 years. Its website says: “Rental Guys Property Management has been helping property owners successfully manage rental homes in Jacksonville and St. Johns County since 2012.”
How much does Rental Guys Property Management charge?
Rental Guys Property Management does not publish its fees on its website. Ask for a written quote that lists the monthly fee, leasing fee and any other charges.
Which areas does Rental Guys Property Management serve?
Its website lists Jacksonville, St. Johns, St. Augustine, Nocatee, Ponte Vedra, Jacksonville Beaches, Mandarin, Southside, Julington Creek, Atlantic Beach and World Golf Village.
What does Rental Guys Property Management manage?
Property types: single-family homes and multi-family. Services: leasing, marketing, maintenance and multi-family management. From the company's website.
What do Google reviewers say about Rental Guys Property Management?
Rental Guys Property Management has a 4.5 rating from 75 Google reviews. Most reviewers mention dependable tenant placement, fair terms, fast responses and caring staff.
How do I get a quote from Rental Guys Property Management?
Use Request a free quote on this page. Your request goes only to Rental Guys Property Management. It is free and there is no obligation.
Compare with other Jacksonville managers
The top Best match companies in Jacksonville. Tick up to 3 to compare and request quotes together.
Rental Guys Property Management
This company
Jacksonville's typical asking rent was $1,589 in September 2026 (+2.5% in a year, Zillow). See the Jacksonville rental market