Looking for a qualified property manager in Clay County?
We can connect you. Tell us about your property and we'll match you with managers who fit. Free, no obligation.
Cities in Clay County
Top property managers in Clay County
Best match across the county: Google rating adjusted for number of reviews.
-
Weichert Realtors - The Coffey Group
★ Highly Recommended · 100+ reviews4.7★ from 109 Google reviews; newest reviews average 5.0★. Score = rating adjusted for review count. Read all reviews on Google1855 Wells Rd Ste 8, Orange Park, FL 32073
Weichert Realtors - The Coffey Group is a full-service property management company managing residential and commercial properties in Orange Park, Jacksonville, Green Cove Springs, Middleburg, St. Johns and Fleming Island.
In their words: “The Coffey Group offers full service management of both residential and commercial properties.”
Review summary: Most reviewers mention a good rental experience, quick responses and fair, helpful managers.
-
FHRM Rental Management
555 Blanding Blvd, Orange Park, FL 32073
FHRM Rental Management is a Lakeside company that has provided residential property management in Clay County for over 10 years.
Review summary: Reviewers often describe a patient, easy-to-reach property manager who responds quickly and handles issues honestly.
-
Green River Property Management
100+ Google reviews4.5★ from 322 Google reviews; newest reviews average 4.6★. Score = rating adjusted for review count. Read all reviews on Google1851 Golden Eagle Way Ste 40, Fleming Island, FL 32003
Green River Property Management has an office in Fleming Island and manages single-family homes in Jacksonville and the First Coast, with marketing, tenant screening, rent collection, maintenance, inspections and owner statements.
In their words: “In addition to Property Management, we specialize in Residential Sales, Investment Properties, Short Sales and Pre-Foreclosures.”
Review summary: Most reviewers mention help finding tenants, an easy leasing process and a pleasant, attentive staff.
-
McWright Property Management - Property Management
🏅 20+ years in business1999 Wells Rd, Orange Park, FL 32073
McWright Property Management, in business since 2003 and focused on property management since 2006, manages multifamily and commercial properties in Jacksonville, Jacksonville Beach, St. Augustine Beach, Ponte Vedra, Nocatee and Orange Park.
In their words: “Our focus has always been property management—delivering value to owners and creating great living experiences for tenants.”
Review summary: Reviewers often describe knowledgeable, kind staff and a smooth rental process.
-
Cool Realty
50+ Google reviews4.5★ from 73 Google reviews; newest reviews average 5.0★. Score = rating adjusted for review count. Read all reviews on Google1857 Wells Rd #207, Orange Park, FL 32073
Cool Realty is a Jacksonville real estate and property management company, serving the area since 2012, managing single-family homes with tenant screening, maintenance and sales in Jacksonville, Orange Park, Fleming Island and Middleburg.
In their words: “From rent collection to maintenance coordination, we handle every detail so you don’t have to.”
Review summary: Most reviewers mention helpful agents, an easy process and responsive help with renting and buying.
-
Gifford Properties & Management
4613 US-17, Fleming Island, FL 32003
Gifford Properties & Management is an independent company with an office in Fleming Island, offering real estate sales and property management, founded almost a decade ago.
Review summary: Reviewers often mention fast repairs, an easy-to-reach manager and long-term care of homes.
-
Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Florida Network Realty
1524-3 County Rd 220 Unit B1, Fleming Island, FL 32003
Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Florida Network Realty has an office in Fleming Island and offers real estate sales along with property management, including listing homes for rent and selecting tenants.
Review summary: Reviewers often mention helpful, understanding agents for home purchases, though one buyer described a failed deal.
-
Integrity Realty & Management
1536 Kingsley Ave Ste 125, Orange Park, FL 32073
Integrity Realty & Management is an Orange Park brokerage specializing in residential sales and property management in the Jacksonville and St. Augustine areas, including leasing and off-market sales.
In their words: “We’ll advertise it, conduct showings to prospective renters, complete background screenings, and prepare the lease.”
Review summary: Reviewers often describe a responsive, reliable and knowledgeable property manager with long-term clients.
-
Shoreward Realty
Circle Ridge Dr, Orange Park, FL 32065
Shoreward Realty is a Lakeside real estate company offering property management, tenant placement, leasing, maintenance and sales in Orange Park, Middleburg, Jacksonville and Clay and Duval counties.
Review summary: Reviewers often describe friendly, courteous staff who respond quickly to maintenance issues.
-
Watson Realty Property Management Orange Park/Middleburg Office
🏅 20+ years in business153 Blanding Blvd, Orange Park, FL 32073
Watson Realty Property Management Orange Park/Middleburg Office is a Watson Property Management office, part of a company operating since 1970, handling single-family rentals with marketing, rent collection, maintenance and evictions.
-
Kellar Realty and Property Management
2219 County Rd 220 Ste 318, Middleburg, FL 32068
Kellar Realty and Property Management has an office in Middleburg and offers residential property management, rentals and real estate sales in Jacksonville and Northeast Florida.
-
PMI Davis Realty
4711 US-17 Ste B2, Fleming Island, FL 32003
PMI Davis Realty is a Property Management Inc franchise office in Fleming Island that manages single-family homes in the Orange Park area, with marketing, screening, rent collection, maintenance, accounting and home watch.
In their words: “We utilize state-of-the-art technology that allows our property owners to know how their investments are doing, while providing tenants real-time access to maintenance requests and billing.”
Review summary: Reviewers often describe an easy, efficient process and a property manager who keeps up with issues.
-
COBRE Professional Property Management
1680 Smith St #4, Orange Park, FL 32073
COBRE Professional Property Management is an Orange Park company specializing in HOA and condo management, including developer turnovers, plus maintenance, janitorial services and real estate sales across Northeast Florida.
Smaller places with listed managers
These places have fewer than 3 companies, so they have no page of their own yet. Their companies appear in the county list above and on nearby city pages.
Middleburg
About Clay County, Florida
Clay County is in central Florida, with about 227,584 residents on 605 square miles of land. Cities with listed property managers include Orange Park, Fleming Island. Nearby counties: Bradford County, Duval County, Putnam County.
- Population
- 227,584
- Land area
- 605 sq mi
- People per sq mi
- 376
- Property managers listed
- 13
Clay County rental market snapshot
Typical rent
$1,805
+2.0% in a year · Zillow
Renter households
20,185
24.1% of homes are rented · Census
Rental vacancy
2%
Share of rentals sitting empty · Census
Median home value
$312,500
Typical rent is 6.9% of home value a year · Census, Zillow
How many people live in Clay County?
Clay County, Florida has about 227,584 residents (Census ACS 2020-2024) and covers 605 square miles of land in central Florida.
What share of homes in Clay County are rented?
24.1% of occupied homes in Clay County are rented, about 20,185 households. Rental vacancy is 2% (Census ACS 2020-2024).
What is the typical rent in Clay County?
Zillow's typical asking rent in Clay County is $1,805, +2.0% in a year. HUD's fair market rent for a 2-bedroom home is $1,694 (FY2027).
How many property management companies serve Clay County?
We list 13 property management companies in Clay County. Their average Google rating is 4.4 from 679 reviews.
Questions to ask before you hire
Ask every manager the same questions and get the answers in writing, so you can compare quotes fairly.
Tick them off as you go. Nothing here is saved or sent.