Property Management Companies in Fairfield County, OH

• Lancaster, OH 4 managers$1,226 +4.1%

• 1RD

  Red Door Equities Management

  ★ Highly Recommended · 100+ reviews4.9★ from 163 Google reviews; newest reviews average 4.6★. Score = rating adjusted for review count. Read all reviews on Google

  721 Union St, Lancaster, OH 43130

  4.9 (163 Google reviews)Recently reviewed

  Red Door Equities Management, based in Lancaster, manages single-family homes, multi-family property and small apartment buildings in Lancaster, Pickaway County, Circleville, Newark and Chillicothe, with leasing, rent collection, lease enforcement and accounting.

  In their words: “We provide intuitive and process-driven property management in Lancaster that covers everything from rent collection to lease enforcement to accounting and resident relationships.”

  Review summary: Most reviewers mention a helpful, polite maintenance team, quick repairs and an easy process.

  (740) 672-5254reddoorequitiesmanagement.com Google profile
  Is this your company? Claim it free Request quote
• 2FR

  Focus Realty and Management

  117 W Main St Ste 207, Lancaster, OH 43130

  4.1 (99 Google reviews)Recently reviewed

  Focus Realty and Management, based in Lancaster, manages single-family homes and apartments in Central Ohio, including Fairfield and Licking Counties, Buckeye Lake, Newark, Circleville and Pataskala, with tenant placement and rent collection.

  In their words: “Whether you’re an established investor or just starting, our dedicated team of real estate professionals is here to help you succeed and thrive.”

  Review summary: Reviewers often mention friendly, honest staff, good communication and maintenance requests completed quickly.

  (740) 901-9090focusrealtyandmanagement.com Google profile
  Is this your company? Claim it free Request quote
• 3OM

  One Management

  121 E 5th Ave #1, Lancaster, OH 43130

  3.0 (33 Google reviews)

  One Management, based in Lancaster, manages apartments, multi-plexes, condos, single-family homes and vacation rentals in Fairfield and Hocking Counties, offering leasing, tenant screening, record keeping and bill paying.

  In their words: “Let us take care of all the logistics of management so you don't have to.”

  (740) 652-6564onemanagementco.com Google profile
  Is this your company? Claim it free Request quote
• 4FH

  Fairfield Homes

  🏅 20+ years in business

  603 W Wheeling St, Lancaster, OH 43130

  3.0 (66 Google reviews)

  Fairfield Homes, based in Lancaster and founded in 1947, develops, builds and manages multifamily and affordable housing communities in Central Ohio and the Midwest, including third-party management for other owners.

  (740) 653-3583fairfieldhomesohio.com Google profile
  Is this your company? Claim it free Request quote

• What is the monthly management fee, and what does it include?Ask whether it is a share of rent collected or a flat amount, and what costs extra.
• Is there a fee to find a tenant (leasing or placement fee)?Also ask about lease renewal fees.
• Do you add a markup to maintenance and repair bills?Ask who does the work and whether you approve large repairs first.
• How long is the contract, and how do I end it?Look for the notice period and any cancellation fee.
• How do you screen tenants?Credit, income, rental history and background checks; ask how they follow fair housing rules.
• How will I see what is happening with my property?Owner portal, monthly statements, how fast they answer you.
• Who handles emergencies at night and on weekends?Ask for the process and typical response time.

Tick them off as you go. Nothing here is saved or sent.