Cities in Fayette County
Top property managers in Fayette County
Best match across the county: Google rating adjusted for number of reviews.
-
Top Shelf Property Management
100+ Google reviews4.8★ from 217 Google reviews; newest reviews average 3.9★. Score = rating adjusted for review count. Read all reviews on Google1795 Alysheba Way Unit 7105, Lexington, KY 40509
Top Shelf Property Management has an office in Lexington and provides full-service management of residential rentals and HOAs, covering rent collection, lease enforcement, maintenance and owner statements.
In their words: “We provide monthly e-statements, yearly account statements, and customized year-end reports so you always know how your investment is performing.”
Review summary: Most reviewers mention understanding, quick-responding staff who resolve issues and make leasing easy.
-
Baughman Property Management, established in 2001, is a family business with an office in Lexington offering apartment homes and full-service management for investors in multi-family properties, including maintenance.
Review summary: Reviewers, mostly former residents, describe helpful, responsive management and well-kept apartments with a convenient online portal.
-
Real Property Management Bluegrass
50+ Google reviews4.6★ from 72 Google reviews; newest reviews average 4.2★. Score = rating adjusted for review count. Read all reviews on Google1908 Bryant Rd Unit 250, Lexington, KY 40509
Real Property Management Bluegrass, part of the Real Property Management franchise, has an office in Lexington and manages single-family and multi-family homes in Lexington, Richmond, Nicholasville and Winchester, with screening, leasing, maintenance and evictions.
In their words: “We are 100% focused on providing quality residential property management service to property owners and residents.”
Review summary: Most reviewers mention helpful, responsive staff and quick answers, and owners note vacant rentals filled efficiently.
-
Rent Lexington Property Management
100+ Google reviews4.5★ from 139 Google reviews; newest reviews average 5.0★. Score = rating adjusted for review count. Read all reviews on GoogleServes the Lexington area · no public office address, so no map pin
Rent Lexington Property Management is a full-service company serving the Lexington area and Central Kentucky, managing single-family homes with marketing, tenant screening, rent collection, maintenance, inspections and evictions.
In their words: “We document all of your expenses and create monthly statements for your review.”
Review summary: Most reviewers mention friendly staff, quick responses and prompt, tidy maintenance work.
-
PURE HomeRiver Property Management of Kentucky
250 E Short St #320, Lexington, KY 40507
PURE HomeRiver Property Management of Kentucky has served the Greater Lexington area since 2007 from an office in Lexington, managing single-family rentals for owners and investors, with rental market analysis.
In their words: “Our property managers live and work in your community, so they know your neighborhood inside and out.”
Review summary: Most reviewers mention responsive staff, timely answers and a quick, easy application and leasing process.
-
Modern Property Management was formed in 2005 and has an office in Lexington, managing single-family homes, multi-family apartment complexes, HOAs and REO properties in Fayette County, with maintenance, accounting, renovation and brokerage.
In their words: “We are a full-service management company providing management, maintenance and accounting services.”
Review summary: Most reviewers mention helpful, responsive staff and an easy leasing and viewing process.
-
Everstead Property Management
834 Porter Pl, Lexington, KY 40508
Everstead Property Management has an office in Lexington and provides full-service management of single-family homes, including tenant placement, rent collection and maintenance coordination, along with property consultation and portfolio management.
Review summary: Reviewers describe an experienced, professional team that communicates well and genuinely cares.
-
Home Forward
356 Longview Plaza #140, Lexington, KY 40503
Home Forward is a locally owned company with an office in Lexington, managing single-family homes, multifamily and mid-term rentals in Central Kentucky, with leasing, tenant screening, rent collection, in-house repairs and inspections.
Review summary: Most reviewers mention a friendly, helpful maintenance team and issues fixed quickly.
-
Sage Real Estate Alliance
2050 Regency Rd Unit D, Lexington, KY 40503
Sage Real Estate Alliance has an office in Lexington and offers real estate, property management, maintenance and investor support services for property owners and renters in the area.
-
Deaton Enterprises
2104, 403 Marquis Ave Ste 303, Lexington, KY 40502
Deaton Enterprises is listed as a property management business with an office in Lexington, Kentucky; its listing does not describe the property types it manages or the areas it covers.
-
Simply Real Estate
476 Doncaster Ct, Lexington, KY 40505
Simply Real Estate is a full-service Central Kentucky property management company with an office in Lexington, handling tenant screening, leasing, rent collection and maintenance for landlords and property owners.
In their words: “Overseeing all aspects of rental property management, including tenant screening, lease agreements, and rent collection.”
-
Hardin Properties launched in 1986 and has an office in Lexington, offering leasing and property management for studios, apartments, duplexes, houses and student housing.
Review summary: Most reviewers, many of them college renters, describe friendly staff and maintenance requests answered quickly through an online portal.
-
MLP Management Co
2828 Easthills Dr, Lexington, KY 40517
MLP Management Co is a property management company with an office in Lexington, Kentucky. Its listing gives few details about the types of property it manages or the areas it serves.
-
Winterwood has specialized in affordable housing since 1979, managing over 340 communities across 8 states, and has an office in Lexington; it also handles construction and development of affordable apartment communities.
-
Kingston Property Management
113 E Loudon Ave, Lexington, KY 40505
Kingston Property Management is a full-service company with an office in Lexington, managing over 850 units including single-family homes, apartment communities and HOAs in Lexington, Louisville, Paris, Richmond and Frankfort.
In their words: “From advertising available units, to screening tenants, and performing and tracking maintenance, we take care of it all.”
-
Cowgill
1999 Richmond Rd #200, Lexington, KY 40502
Cowgill is a family-owned company with an office in Lexington that manages apartment communities, townhomes and student housing, offering third-party management for medium to large market-rate communities along with development work.
In their words: “Our management team has decades of applied experience to ensure efficient, nuanced, and talented management for medium to large market-rate apartment communities.”
-
Classic Real Estate opened its Lexington office in 2000 and offers property management for residential rentals, including tenant placement and maintenance, along with real estate sales.
-
Zahed Property Management
2171 Christian Rd, Lexington, KY 40509
Zahed Property Management has an office in Lexington and manages apartments, single-family homes, duplexes, townhouses and commercial property in Lexington, Mount Sterling and Paris, with leasing, inspections and online rent payment.
-
DellaValle Management
🏅 20+ years in business3151 Beaumont Centre Cir Ste B-100, Lexington, KY 40513
DellaValle Management has served Central Kentucky since 1989 from an office in Lexington, managing HOAs, condominium associations and residential rentals, with handyman and pool services.
In their words: “We help HOAs, COAs, private homeowners and business owners administer and maintain their assets.”
-
Upscale Properties
501 Darby Creek Rd Unit 15, Lexington, KY 40509
Upscale Properties has an office in Lexington and manages homes and apartment complexes in Lexington and Central Kentucky, with rent payment and maintenance services for owners and residents.
In their words: “No matter if you’re looking to rent out your own personal home, an 100 unit apartment complex, or anywhere in- between, we can help.”
Review summary: Most reviewers mention quick maintenance and responsive, attentive management, though a couple report poor communication.
Questions to ask before you hire
Ask every manager the same questions and get the answers in writing, so you can compare quotes fairly.
Tick them off as you go. Nothing here is saved or sent.