Cities in Lake County
Top property managers in Lake County
Best match across the county: Google rating adjusted for number of reviews.
-
PMI NWI
★ Highly Recommended · 100+ reviews4.7★ from 982 Google reviews; newest reviews average 5.0★. Score = rating adjusted for review count. Read all reviews on Google101 W 79th Ave, Merrillville, IN 46410
PMI NWI, part of the PMI franchise, has an office in Merrillville and manages single-family homes, apartments and commercial property in Hammond and Northwest Indiana, from marketing and screening to maintenance and evictions.
In their words: “We leverage state-of-the-art technology to keep property owners informed about the performance of their investments, while providing tenants with real-time access to maintenance requests and billing.”
Review summary: Most reviewers mention helpful, kind staff and quick, thorough maintenance repairs.
-
Austgen Properties is a family-owned company in Griffith that has managed industrial, commercial, residential and storage facilities throughout Northwest Indiana since 1999, including homes, apartments and strip malls.
In their words: “Austgen Properties is a full service managed company specializing in single family homes, apartments, commercial strip malls, industrial properties, and self-storage units.”
Review summary: Reviewers often mention courteous staff, good service and convenient storage options.
-
Prestige Management
100+ Google reviews4.5★ from 162 Google reviews; newest reviews average 3.4★. Score = rating adjusted for review count. Read all reviews on Google315 W 35th Ave, Griffith, IN 46319
Prestige Management, based in Griffith, manages residential rentals in Lake and Porter counties, handling leasing and maintenance and helping owners grow their holdings.
In their words: “Our owners enjoy not only standard portfolio management, but assistance in growing their holdings.”
Review summary: Most reviewers mention understanding, informative staff who explain things thoroughly and resolve issues quickly.
-
Heritage Real Estate Services
9800 Connecticut Dr, Crown Point, IN 46307
Heritage Real Estate Services, based in Merrillville, manages long-term and short-term rentals in Gary, East Chicago, Hammond, Lake Station, Merrillville, Crown Point, Michigan City and Portage, with brokerage, renovation and Section 8 guidance.
Review summary: Reviewers often praise responsive, thorough communication and fast handling of property issues and transactions.
-
Residential Premier Real Estate & Property Management
🏅 10+ years in business8396 Mississippi St Door F -Suite G, Merrillville, IN 46410
Residential Premier Real Estate & Property Management, based in Merrillville, has served Northwest Indiana since 2014 with residential property management, tenant placement and real estate sales.
In their words: “We're more than a real estate company—we’re your dedicated partner for buying, selling, renting, and managing properties.”
Review summary: Reviewers often describe a professional, patient and helpful team, both for home purchases and property issues.
-
Reeder Companies LLC, REALTORS
7007 Indianapolis Blvd, Hammond, IN 46324
Reeder Companies LLC, REALTORS, based in the Woodmar section of Hammond, has managed rental property for more than 70 years, handling single-family homes and small multi-unit buildings in Northwest Indiana.
In their words: “Reeder Companies has been buying, selling, leasing and managing Real Estate for Northwest Indiana for 7 decades, spanning three generations.”
Review summary: Reviewers often mention helpful, kind leasing staff who explain leases patiently and handle maintenance requests quickly.
-
Ballard investments & Properties
3831 Hohman Ave, Hammond, IN 46327
Ballard investments & Properties is a real estate investment company in Hammond that buys, sells and manages residential and commercial properties, also offering seller financing and property acquisitions.
-
Bogs Management
8952 White Oak Ave, Munster, IN 46321
Bogs Management, a family owned company in Munster, provides full-service rental management and real estate sales for apartments, condos, houses and office space in Indiana and Illinois.
In their words: “We have been a family owned Property Management and Real Estate Sales Company for many years.”
-
Real Property Management Northwest Indiana
1171 Breuckman Dr D, Crown Point, IN 46307
Real Property Management Northwest Indiana, part of the Real Property Management brand, has an office in Crown Point and manages single-family homes, duplexes, condos and apartments in Crown Point, Cedar Lake, Dyer, Hammond, Highland, Lowell, Munster and Schererville.
In their words: “We are 100% focused on providing quality residential property management service to property owners and residents.”
Review summary: Reviewers often mention responsive, organized service, good communication and dependable tenant placement over many years.
-
Smg Property Management
8408 W Taft St, Merrillville, IN 46410
Smg Property Management is a property management company with an office in Merrillville, Indiana, handling rental property management for owners in and around Merrillville.
-
Quartermaine Management Services
Serves the Gary area · no public office address, so no map pin
Quartermaine Management Services is a property management company serving the Gary area of Indiana, working with rental property owners in Gary and nearby communities.
-
Big Dog NWI Properties
640 N Rensselaer Ave, Griffith, IN 46319
Big Dog NWI Properties, based in Griffith, is a full-service property management company for residential and small commercial properties in Northwest Indiana, with maintenance, capital improvements and construction oversight.
-
Harmony Property Management
Serves the Valparaiso area · no public office address, so no map pin
Harmony Property Management serves the Merrillville area, managing residential rentals in Lake and Porter counties and providing reporting to property owners.
-
Signature Rental Properties
217 Adelaide Pl, Munster, IN 46321
Signature Rental Properties is a property management company with an office in Munster, Indiana, handling rental property for owners in and around Munster.
-
Liberty Property Mgmt
3141 W 45th Pl, Gary, IN 46408
Liberty Property Mgmt is a family owned company with an office in Ross that has handled property management since 2014 for residential rentals in Griffith and Lake and Porter counties, and also does demolition work.
-
CVS Property Management
🏅 10+ years in businessServes the Gary area · no public office address, so no map pin
CVS Property Management serves the Gary area and has provided full-service management of residential rentals in Gary and Chicago since 2012, including tenant placement, renovations and brokerage.
In their words: “Full-Service Solutions: From leasing and tenant screening to maintenance and rent collection.”
Review summary: Reviewers mostly describe a kind, patient and transparent property manager.
-
Resource Management
1101 Sheffield Ave, Dyer, IN 46311
Resource Management, based in Dyer, manages homeowners associations, single-family homes and multi-unit properties, handling assessment and rent collection, budgets, bill payment, vendor management and financial reconciliation.
In their words: “Resource Management can assist you in finding a full line of rental services from tenant screening, rent collection, and bill payment to landlord legal compliance.”
Review summary: Reviewers often mention quick, patient answers to questions and good customer service from the office staff.
-
Greater Property Solutions
13115 Wicker Ave Ste A #200, Cedar Lake, IN 46303
Greater Property Solutions, with an office in Cedar Lake, manages apartment communities for owners and investors, providing onsite staffing, leasing, rent collection, maintenance coordination, vendor management and compliance.
In their words: “GREATER is a multifamily property management company specializing in apartment communities with 70 units or more.”
-
Silver Hammer Property Management
950 S Wisconsin St, Hobart, IN 46342
Silver Hammer Property Management, based in Hobart, provides management, leasing, inspections and rent collection for single-family homes and multi-unit properties in Lake and Porter counties.
In their words: “Silver Hammer Property Management partners with residential property owners in Lake and Porter Counties in Indiana to further enhance their real estate goals.”
Review summary: Reviewers often describe honest, kind and responsive people who fix issues quickly.
-
One Property Solution
2701 W 45th St, Gary, IN 46408
One Property Solution is a property management company with an office in Ross, Indiana, leasing and managing rental homes for owners in the surrounding area.
-
Bogs Management
8601 Manor Ave E, Munster, IN 46321
Bogs Management is a family owned company in Munster offering full-service rental management and real estate sales for apartments, condos, houses and office space in Indiana and Illinois.
In their words: “We have been a family owned Property Management and Real Estate Sales Company for many years.”
-
Property Boss - Property Management is a family-owned company founded in 2014, with an office in Ross, managing homes, multi-family, condos, townhouses, commercial and HOA properties in Gary, Northwest Indiana and parts of Florida.
In their words: “We handle leasing, marketing, resident screening, rent collection, 24/7 maintenance, lease enforcement, evictions, retained legal counsel, and real estate sales.”
Review summary: Reviewers often mention fast responses to repair requests and good service from the maintenance team.
-
CAPS
7726 W Taft St, Merrillville, IN 46410
CAPS is a property management company with an office in Merrillville, Indiana, renting and managing residential properties for owners in the Merrillville area.
-
Rose Property Management
1846 W 45th St, Munster, IN 46321
Rose Property Management, based in Munster, manages houses, townhomes, condos, apartments, associations and commercial property in Northwest Indiana and Chicagoland, along with real estate sales.
In their words: “Rose Real Estate is a full service brokerage property management company, specializing in houses, townhomes, condominiums, and apartments.”
Smaller places with listed managers
These places have fewer than 3 companies, so they have no page of their own yet. Their companies appear in the county list above and on nearby city pages.
Cedar Lake, Crown Point, Dyer, Hammond, Hobart
Questions to ask before you hire
Ask every manager the same questions and get the answers in writing, so you can compare quotes fairly.
Tick them off as you go. Nothing here is saved or sent.