Cities in Madison County
Top property managers in Madison County
Best match across the county: Google rating adjusted for number of reviews.
-
Blue Pine Property Management
★ User Recommended · 50+ reviews5★ from 62 Google reviews; newest reviews average 5.0★. Score = rating adjusted for review count. Read all reviews on Google343 E 4th N #115, Rexburg, ID 83440
Blue Pine Property Management has a Rexburg office and manages single-family homes, townhomes, condos, duplexes, four-plexes and small apartment buildings in Idaho Falls, St Anthony, Sugar City, Rexburg, Menan, Rigby, Ririe and Ucon.
In their words: “Routine property inspections are also performed to catch potential issues early.”
Review summary: Reviewers often mention a kind, attentive property manager who answers maintenance requests quickly and keeps renters well cared for.
-
Buffalo Property Management
★ User Recommended5★ from 34 Google reviews; newest reviews average 5.0★. Score = rating adjusted for review count. Read all reviews on Google859 S Yellowstone Hwy 2201 suite 2212, Rexburg, ID 83440
Buffalo Property Management is a Rexburg company offering long-term rental management and short-term vacation rental management in Eastern Idaho, from listing and advertising properties to finding and screening tenants.
Review summary: Reviewers, including owners and renters, often mention clear communication, a smooth process and homes rented out quickly.
-
Upper Valley Property Management
★ User Recommended4.9★ from 38 Google reviews; newest reviews average 5.0★. Score = rating adjusted for review count. Read all reviews on Google160 Valley River Dr #2, Rexburg, ID 83440
Upper Valley Property Management is a family-owned company in Rexburg, Idaho, managing single-family homes, duplexes and commercial properties. Its services include marketing, leasing, tenant screening, maintenance, inspections, move-out handling and financial reporting.
In their words: “We offer skilled maintenance technicians along with state-of-the-art technology that allows owners to customize on-demand reports.”
Review summary: Reviewers, mostly tenants, often mention quick responses to repair requests and a manager who is easy to reach.
-
Bus Dudes Property Management
100+ Google reviews4.6★ from 107 Google reviews; newest reviews average 5.0★. Score = rating adjusted for review count. Read all reviews on Google2689 S 2000 W, Rexburg, ID 83440
Bus Dudes Property Management has served Southeast Idaho for 20 years from Rexburg, offering long-term, short-term and HOA management in Idaho Falls, Pocatello, Blackfoot, Rigby and nearby towns, with its own maintenance, remodeling and lawn care crews.
In their words: “That’s why we offer a full range of services designed to make ownership easier, including tenant placement, rent collection, and property maintenance.”
Review summary: Reviewers often mention quick response times, prompt repairs and polite, easy-to-work-with staff.
-
Gemstone Property Management
50+ Google reviews4.6★ from 87 Google reviews; newest reviews average 3.8★. Score = rating adjusted for review count. Read all reviews on Google1109 Summers Dr, Rexburg, ID 83440
Gemstone Property Management is a Rexburg company managing townhomes, condos, single-family homes, HOAs and vacation rentals in Rexburg and Rigby, with leasing, tenant screening, rent collection, owner statements, inspections and maintenance.
Review summary: Reviewers often mention caring staff, quick answers to questions and helpful support when finding and securing a rental.
-
White House Property Management
237 N 2nd E Ste. 212, Rexburg, ID 83440
White House Property Management works from a Rexburg office and has served property owners for nearly a decade, handling maintenance, tenant relations, advertising and turnover of rental properties, including units in Blackfoot.
Review summary: Most reviewers, mainly renters, describe kind staff who reply promptly and fix problems in a timely way.
-
The Nest – Home and Rental Property Management
🏅 20+ years in business1440 Barney Dairy Rd, Rexburg, ID 83440
The Nest – Home and Rental Property Management has served property owners in Rexburg, Idaho since 2006, managing long-term rentals, Airbnb properties and event venues with leasing, screening, rent collection and maintenance coordination.
In their words: “From leasing and maintenance coordination to guest-ready presentation and steady communication, the goal is simple: take good care of the property and make ownership easier.”
Review summary: Reviewers, mostly tenants, describe kind, responsive owners, prompt repairs and well-kept homes.
-
Legacy Rental Management
142 W 1st N, Rexburg, ID 83440
Legacy Rental Management manages single-family homes, apartments, townhomes, mobile homes and student housing in Rexburg, St. Anthony, Rigby, Ashton and East Idaho, with screening, leasing, marketing, rent collection, inspections, maintenance and evictions.
In their words: “From filling vacancies with qualified tenants to collecting rents and efficient maintenance, we can handle it all.”
Review summary: Reviewers, mostly tenants, often mention kind, helpful office staff and prompt maintenance.
-
Axiom Property Management, part of Axiom Properties and Development Inc. and in business since 2005, manages residential and commercial properties in Rexburg, Pocatello, Idaho Falls and Blackfoot, plus St. George, UT and Tucson, AZ, and offers investment analysis.
In their words: “We’re looking for Owners that desire greater passivity to their passive income and we enjoy working with properties that offer a challenge to increasing profitability.”
Review summary: Most tenant reviewers mention prompt, friendly maintenance visits and easy contact with management, with a few unanswered requests.
Questions to ask before you hire
Ask every manager the same questions and get the answers in writing, so you can compare quotes fairly.
Tick them off as you go. Nothing here is saved or sent.