About First In Property Management
First In Property Management has an office in Wesley Chapel and manages single-family homes in Pasco and Hillsborough counties, including Land O' Lakes and Zephyrhills, with marketing, tenant screening, maintenance, an owner portal and real estate sales; its broker has led the team since 2003.
In their words: “We will use comparable rentals to help you determine the accurate amount for your home.”
Review summary: Reviewers often mention a friendly, helpful staff that responds quickly and handles repairs and questions smoothly.
Years in business from the company's website: “L. Michelle Pentifallo - PresidentFirst in Real Estate Services is owned and operated by L. Michelle Pentifallo, a licensed Real Estate Broker. Since 2003, Ms. Pentifallo has led a team of realtors who each have over 20 years of experience in Florida real estate.”
Written by our team from the company's Google listing and website.
What we checked
- Google listing open, checked October 2026
- Manages rentals for other owners (our property-manager check)
- Website read on November 4, 2026
- Newest Google review: September 10, 2026
Not checked by us
- Florida license records (coming soon)
- Fees and contract terms: ask for a written quote
- Insurance
- Service quality beyond Google reviews
No company pays to be listed or ranked. How we choose companies
At a glance
Property types
- Single-family homes
Services
- Marketing
- Tenant screening
- Maintenance
- Owner portal
- Real estate sales
Areas served
- Wesley Chapel
- Lakeland
- Land O' Lakes
- San Antonio
- Tampa
- Trinity
- Zephyrhills
- Hillsborough County
- Pasco County
- Hernando County
- Polk County
- Sumter County
From the company's website, checked November 4, 2026.
How they work with owners
- Rent pricing
- “We will use comparable rentals to help you determine the accurate amount for your home.” Source
Copied word for word from the company's website, read November 4, 2026.
Office and hours
2604 Cypress Ridge Blvd. Suite 102G, Wesley Chapel, FL 33544
| Monday | 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM |
| Tuesday | 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM |
| Wednesday | 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM |
| Thursday | 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM |
| Friday | 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM |
| Saturday | 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Hours from Google. Call ahead to confirm.
Google rating
Topics reviewers mention
- Helpful staff 36
- Lease negotiations 16
- Responsive staff 10
- Rental management 6
- Townhouse 5
- Prompt communication 5
- Quick rental 4
- Prompt issue resolution 3
- Repair management 2
- Landlord experience 2
Source: Google. Newest review September 10, 2026. We show counts only, never review text. Read the reviews on Google
Questions about First In Property Management
Where is First In Property Management located?
First In Property Management's office is at 2604 Cypress Ridge Blvd. Suite 102G, Wesley Chapel, FL 33544.
How long has First In Property Management been in business?
Since 2003, about 23 years. Its website says: “L. Michelle Pentifallo - PresidentFirst in Real Estate Services is owned and operated by L. Michelle Pentifallo, a licensed Real Estate Broker. Since 2003, Ms. Pentifallo has led a team of realtors who each have over 20 years of experience in Florida real estate.”
How much does First In Property Management charge?
First In Property Management does not publish its fees on its website. Ask for a written quote that lists the monthly fee, leasing fee and any other charges.
Which areas does First In Property Management serve?
Its website lists Wesley Chapel, Lakeland, Land O' Lakes, San Antonio, Tampa, Trinity, Zephyrhills, Hillsborough County, Pasco County, Hernando County, Polk County and Sumter County.
What does First In Property Management manage?
Property types: single-family homes. Services: marketing, tenant screening, maintenance, owner portal and real estate sales. From the company's website.
What do Google reviewers say about First In Property Management?
First In Property Management has a 4.2 rating from 163 Google reviews. Reviewers often mention a friendly, helpful staff that responds quickly and handles repairs and questions smoothly.
How do I get a quote from First In Property Management?
Use Request a free quote on this page. Your request goes only to First In Property Management. It is free and there is no obligation.
Compare with other Wesley Chapel managers
The top Best match companies in Wesley Chapel. Tick up to 3 to compare and request quotes together.
First In Property Management
This company
Wesley Chapel's typical asking rent was $2,209 in September 2026 (−0.2% in a year, Zillow). See the Wesley Chapel rental market